← Guides · By Ray Lei · Published 2026-11-16

What's the difference between sukiyaki and shabu-shabu?

Sukiyaki is sweet and rich: thin beef is cooked in a shallow iron pan with a soy sauce, mirin and sugar sauce, along with tofu, leeks, mushrooms and shirataki noodles, and each bite is dipped in beaten raw egg. Shabu-shabu is light and clean: you swish thin beef or pork through a pot of plain kombu (kelp) broth for a few seconds and dip it in ponzu (citrus soy) or goma-dare (sesame sauce).

Sukiyaki (すき焼き) Shabu-shabu (しゃぶしゃぶ)
Pot Shallow cast-iron pan Deep pot, often with a chimney or divided
Cooking liquid Warishita: soy, mirin, sugar, sake Kombu dashi, mostly unseasoned
How meat is cooked Simmered or seared in the sauce Swished through simmering broth a few times
Dip Beaten raw egg Ponzu and goma-dare
Flavor Sweet-salty, rich Light; flavor comes from the sauces
Typical add-ins Tofu, negi, shiitake, shungiku, shirataki Napa cabbage, tofu, mushrooms, carrots, kudzu or udon noodles
Finish (shime) Udon in the leftover sauce Rice porridge (zosui) or noodles in the broth

Kanto vs Kansai sukiyaki

In the Kanto (Tokyo) style, ingredients simmer in premixed warishita. In the Kansai (Osaka, Kyoto) style, beef is seared first with sugar and soy sauce added directly to the pan. Either way, staff at sukiyaki restaurants often cook the first round for you.

How to eat shabu-shabu

  1. Wait for the broth to simmer.
  2. Hold a slice of meat with chopsticks and swish it through the broth until it just turns color.
  3. Dip it in ponzu (add grated daikon and scallions) or sesame sauce.
  4. Add vegetables and tofu to the pot as you go, and skim the foam (aku) with the ladle.
  5. Finish with rice or noodles in the broth.

Allergy and diet notes

Sukiyaki sauce contains soy and wheat. The raw egg dip is optional; ask for it without if you avoid raw egg. Goma-dare contains sesame and sometimes peanuts; ponzu contains soy and sometimes fish. Shabu-shabu broth is often kombu only, but some restaurants add bonito.

ChefBear helps you pick between hot pot menus: AI suggestions for what to order, a memory of the hot pot you liked, photos of each set and translations of Japanese course names.

Frequently asked questions

Which is healthier, sukiyaki or shabu-shabu?

Shabu-shabu is lighter, since the broth isn't sweetened and the meat is cooked briefly.

Is the raw egg in sukiyaki safe?

Eggs sold in Japan are generally handled to be eaten raw. If you prefer to skip it, ask for no egg.

Can I get pork shabu-shabu?

Yes. Buta-shabu (pork) is common, and many places offer beef and pork.

Is shabu-shabu the same as Chinese hot pot?

They're similar in method. Chinese hot pot usually uses a seasoned or spicy broth and a sauce bar; shabu-shabu uses a light kombu broth.

Related guides