What's the difference between chicken tikka masala and butter chicken?
Both start with chicken tikka, marinated in yogurt and spices and cooked in a tandoor. Butter chicken (murgh makhani) goes into a smooth tomato sauce enriched with butter and cream; it's mellow and a little sweet. Chicken tikka masala goes into a tomato-onion sauce that's tangier and more spiced, often with chunks of onion and pepper. Recipes overlap a lot from one restaurant to the next, so the two can taste close.
| Butter chicken | Tikka masala | Korma | Vindaloo | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base | Tomato, butter, cream | Tomato, onion, cream or yogurt | Yogurt, cream, ground nuts or seeds | Vinegar, chili, garlic |
| Typical heat | Mild | Mild to medium | Mildest | Hot |
| Taste | Rich, smooth, a bit sweet | Tangy, spiced, smoky from tandoori chicken | Creamy, nutty, fragrant | Sour, fiery |
| Common allergens | Dairy; sometimes cashew | Dairy; sometimes cashew or almond | Dairy; usually cashew or almond | Varies; ask |
| Origin story | Delhi, Moti Mahal restaurant | Claimed by several British restaurants | Mughal court cooking | Goa, from Portuguese vinha d'alhos |
Butter chicken
Murgh makhani is credited to Delhi's Moti Mahal restaurant, which simmered leftover tandoori chicken in a tomato and butter gravy. Dried fenugreek leaves (kasuri methi) are the signature aroma. Many restaurants add cashew paste to thicken it, so ask if you have a nut allergy.
Chicken tikka masala
Tikka means pieces; masala means a spice mix or a sauce made from one. The dish is closely tied to Indian restaurants in Britain, and several restaurateurs there have claimed to have created it. Expect more onion, more coriander and cumin, and a brighter tomato flavor than butter chicken.
Korma and vindaloo
Korma is the pick for someone who wants no heat at all: meat braised in yogurt and cream with ground nuts or seeds and warm spices. Vindaloo is the opposite end. It comes from Goa, where the name traces back to a Portuguese dish of meat in wine vinegar and garlic. Restaurant vindaloo is usually one of the hottest dishes on the menu.
Ordering tips
- Want the vegetarian version: paneer butter masala or paneer tikka masala uses cheese cubes instead of chicken
- Have a nut allergy: ask whether the gravy contains cashew, almond or melon seed paste
- Avoiding dairy: all four are hard; a chana masala or a dal without butter or cream is easier
- Pair with garlic naan or plain basmati rice
ChefBear can point you to the right curry for your taste on that night's menu, remember that you liked the korma, show you what each dish looks like and translate the Hindi names.
Frequently asked questions
Which is spicier, tikka masala or butter chicken?
Tikka masala is usually a bit spicier and tangier. Both are mild by Indian restaurant standards, and most places can adjust the heat.
Is butter chicken the same as chicken makhani?
Yes. Murgh makhani means butter chicken in Hindi.
Which is the mildest Indian curry?
Korma is generally the mildest. Butter chicken and dal makhani are also mild at most restaurants.
Does tikka masala have nuts?
Some recipes include cashew or almond paste and some don't. Ask the restaurant if you have a nut allergy.