What should I order at an Italian restaurant?
For a first visit, pick one pasta whose sauce you can picture: carbonara (egg, pecorino, guanciale, black pepper), cacio e pepe (pecorino and pepper), amatriciana (tomato and guanciale) or ragù alla bolognese (slow-cooked meat sauce). Share an antipasto like burrata or fried calamari. At an Italian-American place, one plate per person is plenty; at a regional Italian restaurant, pasta portions are smaller and meant to be followed by a main.
Two kinds of Italian restaurant
Read the menu for a minute before ordering. If you see chicken parm, baked ziti, shrimp scampi and garlic bread, it's Italian-American: big portions, one plate each, often with a side of pasta. If the menu is divided into antipasti, primi, secondi, contorni and the pastas are named for regions or shapes, it's closer to how people eat in Italy. Two people often share an antipasto, each get a primo, then split a secondo.
Pasta sauces, decoded
| Name on the menu | What's in it |
|---|---|
| Carbonara | Egg yolk, pecorino romano, guanciale (cured pork cheek), black pepper. No cream in the Roman version |
| Cacio e pepe | Pecorino romano, black pepper and starchy pasta water |
| Amatriciana | Tomato, guanciale, pecorino, sometimes chili |
| Arrabbiata | Tomato, garlic and dried chili; "arrabbiata" means angry |
| Puttanesca | Tomato, olives, capers, anchovy, garlic |
| Bolognese / ragù | Meat sauce cooked for hours with a little tomato, wine and milk |
| Alfredo | Butter and parmesan. The cream-heavy version is Italian-American |
| Pesto (alla genovese) | Basil, pine nuts, parmesan or pecorino, garlic, olive oil |
| Vongole | Clams, garlic, white wine, parsley |
| Aglio, olio e peperoncino | Garlic, olive oil, chili. Simple and good |
Mains you'll see
- Parmigiana: breaded chicken or veal (or eggplant) topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella, then baked
- Piccata: thin cutlets in lemon, butter and caper sauce
- Marsala: cutlets with mushrooms in Marsala wine sauce
- Saltimbocca: veal with prosciutto and sage, pan-cooked in wine
- Osso buco: braised veal shank, often served with risotto alla milanese
- Branzino: whole or filleted European sea bass, usually grilled
Starters and sides
Burrata (mozzarella with a creamy center), caprese (tomato, mozzarella, basil), arancini (fried risotto balls), fried calamari and bruschetta are the usual antipasti. Contorni are vegetable sides ordered separately, like roasted potatoes or sautéed spinach.
Dessert
Tiramisu (coffee-soaked ladyfingers with mascarpone), panna cotta (set cream), cannoli (fried shells with sweet ricotta) and affogato (espresso over gelato).
If you can't tell a pappardelle from a paccheri, ChefBear reads the menu and recommends what to order from it, remembers which sauces you like, shows what each dish looks like and translates the Italian names.
Frequently asked questions
What is the most popular dish at an Italian restaurant?
It depends on the restaurant. At Italian-American places, chicken parmigiana, spaghetti and meatballs, fettuccine Alfredo and lasagna are staples. At Roman-style places, carbonara and cacio e pepe are common orders.
Does carbonara have cream?
The Roman recipe doesn't. The creaminess comes from egg yolk and pecorino emulsified with pasta water. Some American restaurants add cream.
What is the difference between a primo and a secondo?
A primo is the first course, usually pasta, risotto or soup. A secondo is the main course of meat or fish, often served without sides; you order vegetables (contorni) separately.
What is guanciale?
Guanciale is cured pork cheek. It's the traditional pork in carbonara and amatriciana. Some restaurants use pancetta (cured pork belly) instead.